|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 4 | Page : 389-396
Visiting Nurses' Perspectives on Practices to Achieve End-of-Life Cancer Patients' Wishes for Death at Home: A Qualitative Study
Noriko Teruya, Yoko Sunagawa, Haru Sunagawa, Takehiko Toyosato
School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of the Ryukyus, Nishihara, Okinawa Prefecture, Japan
|Date of Submission||21-Dec-2018|
|Date of Acceptance||16-Apr-2019|
|Date of Web Publication||29-Jul-2019|
Faculty of Medicine, University of the Ryukyus, Nishihara, Okinawa Prefecture
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Objective: This study aimed to clarify visiting nurses' perspectives on critical practices to ensure they could advocate for patients who prefer to die at home. Methods: Sixteen nurses, working at home-visit nursing agencies in Japan, participated in this study. Data were generated by interviews with the nurses and participant observations from nursing home-visits for six end-of-life cancer patients and were analyzed using content analysis. Results: Five themes emerged: (1) nursing assessment, (2) support for comfortable daily life of the patient and their family, (3) advocating for the patient's views about continuing homecare until death, (4) supporting the patient's preparedness for death, and (5) coordination with other health professionals and related facilities for a comfortable environment for the patient. In addition, the nurses sometimes used humorous responses to death-related work to change the patient's melancholy thoughts. Conclusion: The present study found that the participants advocated for the patient's views about continuing homecare until death while coordinating views between the patient and their family; they further supported the patient's daily life while helping them prepare for death to achieve their wish for death at home. In addition, our study uncovered the visiting nurses' unconscious practical wisdom of using humorous responses to death-related work to alleviate the patients' feelings of hopelessness. To develop practical wisdom for using humor effectively in end-of-life care, nurses need to verbalize unconscious practices, and accumulate empirical knowledge about nursing interventions using humor, including cultural attitudes, through case study analysis.
Keywords: Dying cancer patient, palliative home care, qualitative research, visiting nurse
|How to cite this article:|
Teruya N, Sunagawa Y, Sunagawa H, Toyosato T. Visiting Nurses' Perspectives on Practices to Achieve End-of-Life Cancer Patients' Wishes for Death at Home: A Qualitative Study. Asia Pac J Oncol Nurs 2019;6:389-96
|How to cite this URL:|
Teruya N, Sunagawa Y, Sunagawa H, Toyosato T. Visiting Nurses' Perspectives on Practices to Achieve End-of-Life Cancer Patients' Wishes for Death at Home: A Qualitative Study. Asia Pac J Oncol Nurs [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 Dec 9];6:389-96. Available from: http://www.apjon.org/text.asp?2019/6/4/389/263424
| Introduction|| |
In Japan, cancer is the primary cause of death in 28.9% of the population; the annual number of deaths exceeded 370,000 in 2016. Annual morbidity predictions for cancer also exceed 1 million cases and are growing steadily. The 2017 revised basic plan to promote cancer control programs, based on the cancer control act in Japan, clearly states its goals as “building a society that can live with dignity with peace of mind.”
According to a government survey, in the case of a terminal illness, 54.6% of citizens wish to pass away at home. In a survey in Okinawa prefecture, 53.0% of respondents in all age groups answered that they wished to be cared for at home until death if they reach a terminal phase. The traditional religious view of life, in which death at home is ideal, is still maintained in Okinawa. However, the actual home death rate of cancer patients was reported to be only 13.3% in Japan and 11.8% in Okinawa, while >80% died in hospital, and death at home in cancer patients was strongly affected by “access to home medical care.” Behind this trend is the palliative care system situation in Japan, which is not adequately prepared to care for patients dying at home. With the advent of a future super-aged society, unlike any other in history, and considering both the increase in the number of deaths from cancer and the growing need for care at home, visiting nurses have critical roles to play in supporting dying patients who wish to stay at home, even if the system is not prepared.
Previous investigations of visiting nurses who care for cancer patients have focused on nurses' thoughts regarding terminal patients' transition from hospital to home,, difficulties and barriers in-home palliative care,,,, care for family members who carry out the dying patient's care,, and agency- and service-related factors associated with home-based end-of-life care., These studies suggest that it is difficult to continue home care until a patient's death if there are misunderstandings by patients and their families regarding such care, caregiver shortages,,, and lack of collaboration among homecare professionals.,,,, Despite the need to facilitate and expand the roles of visiting nurses, few studies have investigated concrete practices to fulfill the wishes of terminal patients to stay at home until their deaths. The present study, therefore, aimed to examine visiting nurses' critical practices to ensure that they can advocate for patients who prefer to die at home. By clarifying these nursing practices in home palliative care, it will be possible to contribute to care strategies that facilitate patients' wishes to be cared for and die in their own homes and to provide critical suggestions regarding nursing education on this pressing topic.
| Methods|| |
In this study, 16 visiting nurses were chosen, using a purposive sampling strategy. Participants were working at two home-visit nursing agencies in Okinawa, Japan, which support more than 20 home deaths of end-of-life cancer patients annually. Participants also had prior experience in supporting two patients' deaths in similar situations during the previous year.
The data were generated through semi-structured interviews with the 16 visiting nurses and participant observations from home nursing visits for six terminal patients.
Participants were interviewed in quiet locations at their home-visit nursing agencies, as was convenient to the participants. Each interview lasted between 40 and 70 min. The main interview questions were: “How do you provide care for end-of-life cancer patients and their family members to achieve the patient's wishes for death at home?” and “on a routine basis, what do you do to pay attention to end-of-life cancer patients and their family members for continuing their home care until death?” The interviews covered the nurses' perspectives and experiences regarding their provision of support for the patients to achieve their wishes for death at home. In addition, probing follow-up questions were asked during the interviews to clarify their responses. The interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim.
Approximately 6 h (1 h/patient) of participant observations were conducted during the nursing home-visit by using the participant-as-observer method. The participants' observations aimed to understand how nurses cared practically for terminal patients and their families, to verify conformance with interviews, and to explore nonverbalized unconscious practical wisdom from the interviews. Field notes were recorded from the participants' observations, and transcriptions of the field notes were coded for each nursing visit.
The data were analyzed using reference to Graneheim and Lundman's method of content analysis as follows:First, the transcriptions of the interviews and field notes of participants' observations were read through several times to obtain a sense of the whole. Second, these texts were divided into condensed meaning units. These units were labeled with codes; the number of participants who commented on each code's contents was counted. The codes were then sorted into subcategories and categories, based on comparisons regarding their similarities and differences. Finally, themes were formulated regarding the expression of the latent content of the text.
To establish credibility, member checking was used. The researchers ensured the depth of content and its authenticity by thoroughly identifying diverse data through several discussions and clarifications among the researchers until a consensus was reached. After completing the analysis, a summary of the interviews and the result of the interviews' coding and categorization were returned to the participants; they confirmed that the researchers had represented their perspectives and experiences.
The study was approved by the ethics committee of the University of the Rykyus, Okinawa, Japan (Approval No. 313). All the participants were informed about the study's purpose and methods. They were informed that participation in the study was voluntary and that they could refuse to participate or withdraw from the study at any time, without having any negative impact. Regarding participant observations, the patients were informed about the study's purpose and methods from a researcher and the managers of the nursing agencies. We conducted participant observations of nursing home-visits as well as asking for patient's agreement to observations.
| Results|| |
All participants were female and were generalist nurses who had graduated from vocational school; their ages ranged from 34 to 59 years (mean, 44.1; [standard deviation [SD] = 7.9). Their years of nursing experience ranged from 10 to 39 years (mean, 19.7; [SD] = 7.7), and their homecare nursing experience ranged from 2 to 12 years (mean, 5.1; [SD] = 3.7).
Palliative nursing practices' themes
During the data analysis, five themes emerged. [Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3] present the identified themes, categories, sub-categories, and examples of typical codes. The codes emerging from the interviews and the participant observations were almost the same. Each theme is discussed briefly.
|Table 1: Themes, categories, sub-categories, and examples of typical codes of visiting nurses' practices to continue home care for patients dying from cancer until their deaths|
Click here to view
|Table 2: Themes, categories, sub-categories, and examples of typical codes of visiting nurses' practices to continue home care for patients dying from cancer until their deaths (continued)|
Click here to view
|Table 3: Themes, categories, sub-categories, and examples of typical codes of visiting nurses' practices to continue home care for patients dying from cancer until their deaths (continued)|
Click here to view
The participants evaluated the preparedness for the patients' home care based on their “assessment of the patient's and their family's understanding of their disease conditions and prognosis” and “the family member's status.” They also evaluated the possibilities of continuing home care until the patient's death based on their assessment of “caregiver burden,” “patient's physical status,” and “the family's preparedness for continuing the patient's home care.”
Support for the comfortable daily life of the patient and their family
The participants provided a sense of security to the patients and their families through “providing 24-h consultation,” “providing patient symptom management,” “providing an explanation to the family about the patient's disease condition,” “making opportunities for the patient and their family to be together,” and “coordinating the home-visit nursing schedule according to their needs.” They also created a comfortable environment for the patients' home care through “giving advice regarding nursing care and management of the patient's symptoms,” “giving a sense of empowerment to the family in caring for the patient,” and “providing information about available home care services and materials.”
Advocating for the patient's views about continuing home care until death
The participants confirmed not only the patient's wishes but also the family's thoughts about continuing the patient's home care, and coordinated views between the patient and their family members in the case of disagreement.
Supporting preparedness for the patient's death
The participants supported preparedness for the patient's peaceful death with the patient and their family and gave ongoing emotional support to bereaved families. When patients talked about their own deaths, such as they wanted to die, or there was no meaning in life, the participants sometimes delivered humorous replies as a means of alleviating these concerns. These nursing practices were only found during the participants' observations when a researcher asked the participants to verbalize their practices. As a result, the sub-category of “care for the patient's emotional and spiritual needs using humorous replies” emerged.
Coordination with other health professionals and related facilities for the patients' comfortable environments
The participants collected further information about the patients through joint meetings with hospital staff and other homecare professionals. They also previously discussed necessary care with hospital nurses, patients, and their families; consulted with hospital nurses on the required methods for special medical treatments, such as the management of respiratory, colostomy care, and peritoneal dialysis during patient's hospitalization; and requested that the hospital keep a bed available for the patient if necessary in case of acute hospitalization and family care burden. The participants collaborated closely with the patients' home doctors for relief of pain and anxiety, relaying the prognosis prediction to patients, and supporting the patients' wishes for death at home. In addition, they collaborated with other professionals such as homecare workers, care managers, and social welfare workers to improve patient comfort.
| Discussion|| |
The present study clarified five themes of visiting nurses' critical practices of providing care to an end-of-life cancer patient who prefers to die at home, in order to ensure they can advocate for the patient as follows: (1) nursing assessment, (2) support for the comfortable daily life of the patient and their family, (3) advocating for the patient's views about continuing home care until death, (4) supporting the patient's preparedness for death, and (5) coordination with other health professionals and related facilities for a comfortable environment for the patient. In addition, a characteristic practice in this study was that the participants sometimes used humor in their established rapport with patients as a response to death-related work to alleviate the patients' feelings of hopelessness.
The participants confirmed their understanding of the patient's condition and prognosis and also inquired about the patient's advance directives. Silveira et al. found that patients who had prepared advance directives received care that was strongly associated with their preferences. This indicates that advance care planning practiced by nurses for terminal cancer patients may contribute to the patients achieving their goal of passing away at home. To achieve this and to honor patients' wishes, it is important for visiting nurses to continue to offer predictive prognosis to patients and their families and to repeatedly confirm a patient's willingness to stay at home until death. In addition, in terms of the patient's family, bereaved family members who cared for dying patients at home in accordance with the patient's wishes reported positive outcomes (e.g., feelings of accomplishment, improved family relationships) and felt personal growth through their caring experiences. This suggests that supporting a patient's wishes leads to positive outcomes overall for the patient's family.
Conversely, in a survey in Okinawa, respondents who did not want to die at home in the case of reaching a terminal phase responded that way primarily because they did not want to make trouble for their families. In Japan, there was a high prevalence of entrusting end-of-life decisions to the family as opposed to the individual, when compared with Western countries. The general population in Japan might tend to emphasize relationships with others rather than autonomy. These results suggest that patients might not reveal their true willingness to stay at home, out of consideration for their families. Because of these concerns, visiting nurses need to uncover patients' true thoughts, elicit an emotion, then reconcile opposing points of views regarding home care between patients and their families.
Each of the participants had discussions about necessary care with patients, their families, and hospital staff, to prepare for home care and give a sense of security while the patient was still hospitalized. During the patients' home care, the participants provided 24-h care support for them so that they could live with security. In a survey of people who provided care at home for family members with terminal cancer, caregivers often expressed a high rate of difficulty related to the “patient's pain and condition,” with approximately 60%–80% of them having concerns about “care burden.” Because of these concerns, the coordination of necessary medical care, including pain control and other relief, is emphasized. This sense of security is a significant component of well-being for patients and their families and underpins heightened confidence about their ongoing daily lives. Poor discharge planning, poor coordination of necessary medical care, including pain control and other relief, and family care burden were barriers to dying at home and promoters of hospital admission. Taking these precautions will provide patients and their families with a sense of security and trust; therefore, visiting nurses are required to prioritize this collaboration between hospital staff and homecare professions, coordinating treatment planning before home care begins. In addition, this indicates that better comprehension of caregivers' experiences can help professional nursing staff to understand what will promote caregiver confidence. Thus, nurses need to understand the experiences of caregivers fully and give proper attention to their physical and mental condition.
The participants also supported the patient's family as they spent quality time with the patient while recommending patient massage to provide the family with physical contact. Opportunities for the family to participate in care using massage improved relationships between the patient and their family, and helped to prepare the family to deal with the patient's death. This suggests that nursing practices that create opportunities for offering close physical contact between the patient and their family also promoted spiritual well-being.
The present study uncovered the visiting nurses' nonverbalized and unconscious practical wisdom of using humorous responses to death-related work with patients through the participant observations. Light-hearted talk of death has been shown to have a psychological effect of detaching the terminally ill from their own deaths. Using humor in palliative care reduced emotional tension and stress, fostered relationships between patients and healthcare workers,, had efficacy for pain relief and improved coping skills and quality of life.,,, These outcomes were obtained from studies in the Western-European cultural setting, and we found no study on nursing interventions using humor in Japanese palliative care. However, it appeared that our study's participants subconsciously created an emotional atmosphere that allowed the expression of grief by delivering humorous replies to the patients' gloomy thoughts about their deaths. To develop practical wisdom and build a solid empirical foundation for using humor effectively in end-of-life care, nurses need to verbalize unconscious practices and accumulate empirical knowledge about nursing interventions using humor, including cultural attitudes, through case study analysis.
As mentioned, we clarified the critical practices of visiting nurses to ensure that they could advocate for patients who preferred to die at home. When it comes to the concept of a “good death,” most Japanese people have emphasized physical and psychological comfort, environmental comfort and dying in a favorite place, a good relationship with family and medical staff, maintaining hope and pleasure, not being a burden to others, and being respected as an individual. The nursing practices identified from the present study met these requirements of a good death. At the same time, we uncovered the core clinical competencies required for this care. These findings will help expand our understanding of how visiting nurses might actively engage in constructing homecare systems to assess and support terminal patients and their families appropriately so that they might achieve the patient's peaceful death at home. Toward the advent of the future super-aged society, we need to cultivate nurses who are not only capable of these comprehensive practices but who also have the skills to use humor appropriately in palliative care based on a solid empirical foundation, to contribute to the quality of life of end-of-life patients and their families.
This study is limited through being based on two home-visit nursing agencies in Okinawa, Japan, so the results may not support broader generalization. Therefore, it is unlikely to reflect the state of other countries with different healthcare systems. However, our detailing of common nursing practices for terminal patients undergoing home care may help provide appropriate strategies across cultures.
| Conclusion|| |
The present study found that the participants advocated for the patients' views about continuing home care until death while coordinating views between the patients and their families; they further supported the patients' daily lives while helping their preparedness for death to achieve their wishes for death at home. These findings contribute to the care strategies for supporting end-of-life cancer patients and their families' wishes to empower them to face death in the comfort of their own home. In addition, our study uncovered the visiting nurses' unconscious practical wisdom of using humorous responses to death-related work with patients to alleviate the patients' feelings of hopelessness. To develop practical wisdom and build a solid empirical foundation for effectively using humor in end-of-life care, nurses need to verbalize unconscious practices so that the scientific community can accumulate their experiences and scientific knowledge about nursing interventions using humor.
The authors are grateful to all of the participants in this study.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Director-General for Statistics and Information Policy. Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare. Vital Statistics in Japan: Trend up to 2016. Tokyo: Ministry of Health Labor Welfare. Available from: https://www.mhlw.go.jp/toukei/list/dl/81-1a2.pdf
. [Last accessed on 2018 Nov 29].
Katanoda K, Kamo K, Saika K, Matsuda T, Shibata A, Matsuda A, et al.
Short-term projection of cancer incidence in Japan using an age-period interaction model with spline smoothing. Jpn J Clin Oncol 2014;44:36-41.
Kondo N. Traditional religion and terminal care in the Ryukyus, Southern Japan. Nihon Koshu Eisei Zasshi 1992;39:799-808.
Igarashi M, Satou K, Shimizu M, Kanno Y, Kanno K, Kawahara R, et al
. Factors affecting death at home. Palliat Care Res 2014;9:114-21.
Kasai Y. Cognition and decision making of home care nurse regarding the transition from hospital to home or terminal cancer patients. J Jpn Soc Cancer Nurs 2006;20:39-50.
Danielsen BV, Sand AM, Rosland JH, Førland O. Experiences and challenges of home care nurses and general practitioners in home-based palliative care – A qualitative study. BMC Palliat Care 2018;17:95.
Osono Y, Ishi Y, Miyashita M. Obstacles to continued home care for terminal cancer patients from perspective of visiting nurse. J Jpn Soc Cancer Nurs 2015;29:44-53.
O'Brien M, Jack B. Barriers to dying at home: The impact of poor co-ordination of community service provision for patients with cancer. Health Soc Care Community 2010;18:337-45.
Jack B, O'Brien M. Dying at home: Community nurses' views on the impact of informal carers on cancer patients' place of death. Eur J Cancer Care (Engl) 2010;19:636-42.
Osono Y, Ishi Y, Miyashita M. Issues and solutions with the care of end-of-life cancer patients at home from the perspective of visiting nurses. J Jpn Soc Cancer Nurs 2012;26:52-60.
Saiki C, Itoh E, Tadaka E, Arimoto A, Okochi A, Shiratani K, et al
. Experience and support of family caregivers of terminal cancer patients in approaching death at home from the view point of home visiting nurses. J Jpn Acad Community Health Nurs 2015;18:56-64.
Furuse M. Visiting nurses' support for the mental uncertainty experienced by families of terminal cancer patients during care. Jpn J Res Fam Nurs 2014;19:90-100.
Igarashi A, Kurinobu T, Ko A, Okamoto Y, Matsuura S, Feng M, et al.
Factors related to the provision of home-based end-of-life care among home-care nursing, home help, and care management agencies in Japan. BMC Res Notes 2015;8:434.
Nakanishi M, Niimura J, Nishida A. Factors associated with end-of-life by home-visit nursing-care providers in Japan. Geriatr Gerontol Int 2017;17:991-8.
Downe-Wamboldt B. Content analysis: Method, applications, and issues. Health Care Women Int 1992;13:313-21.
Silveira MJ, Kim SY, Langa KM. Advance directives and outcomes of surrogate decision making before death. N
Engl J Med 2010;362:1211-8.
Ishikawa T, Fukui S, Okamoto Y. Advance care planning and home death in patients with advanced cancer: A structured interview analysis. Int J Palliat Nurs 2018;24:418-26.
Koop PM, Strang VR. The bereavement experience following home-based family caregiving for persons with advanced cancer. Clin Nurs Res 2003;12:127-44.
Wong WK, Ussher J, Perz J. Strength through adversity: Bereaved cancer carers' accounts of rewards and personal growth from caring. Palliat Support Care 2009;7:187-96.
Voltz R, Akabayashi A, Reese C, Ohi G, Sass HM. End-of-life decisions and advance directives in palliative care: A cross-cultural survey of patients and health-care professionals. J Pain Symptom Manage 1998;16:153-62.
Ishii Y, Miyashita M, Sato K, Ozawa T. A family's difficulties in caring for a cancer patient at the end of life at home in Japan. J Pain Symptom Manage 2012;44:552-62.
McKenzie H, Boughton M, Hayes L, Forsyth S, Davies M, Underwood E, et al.
Asense of security for cancer patients at home: The role of community nurses. Health Soc Care Community 2007;15:352-9.
Soroka JT, Froggatt K, Morris S. Family caregivers' confidence caring for relatives in hospice care at home: An exploratory qualitative study. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2018;35:1540-6.
Minami Y, Hayama Y, Oishi F. The effectiveness of nursing intervention in providing an opportunity for family members to participate in the care of terminal cancer patients – The use of aroma massage. J Chiba Acad Nurs Sci 2014;20:39-46.
Langley-Evans A, Payne S. Light-hearted death talk in a palliative day care context. J Adv Nurs 1997;26:1091-7.
Dean RA, Gregory DM. More than trivial: Strategies for using humor in palliative care. Cancer Nurs 2005;28:292-300.
Claxton-Oldfield S, Bhatt A. Is there a place for humor in hospice palliative care? Volunteers say “Yes”! Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2017;34:417-22.
Ridley J, Dance D, Pare D. The acceptability of humor between palliative care patients and health care providers. J Palliat Med 2014;17:472-4.
Miyashita M, Sanjo M, Morita T, Hirai K, Uchitomi Y. Good death in cancer care: A nationwide quantitative study. Ann Oncol 2007;18:1090-7.
| Authors|| |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]